Friday, 12 February 2010

What to do when someone copies your top ranking website content (and domain name)?

Hhhm... a new issue that raised it's ugly head today... I have discovered that someone has taken by top ranking .co.uk domain name and registered a .com version, which in itself is fine. It's a UK site and the .co.uk is the one to have as far as I am concerned, but not only have the copied the domain name, they've also lifted large chunks of the website.... the main pages are essentially the same with badly designed headers, and different link urls & phone numbers. Oh, and did I say badly designed?

This has been done to 2 geographically relevant sites and we have had complaints from unhappy customers who think they're dealing with us. The strange thing is that most of the content is lists of specialist equipment that we have for rental, and that the imitator can't have most of it available (it's a small market and we know who has what) so it's been done purely as these sites were high ranking, possibly to support some other business.

So what to do? Well at 5.30pm on a Friday the options were a little limited but I will be detailing what I do and how I get on in this blog.

Some people say call - discuss, but as this is a clear cut case of trading on our reputation it's not the first thing I've done. My first course of action was to a run a whois check, plus basic DNS record checking. The registrant is based in Glasgow and is listed as having about 538 domains. I found the  Registration Service Provider: and requested that they remove the offending material (in this case it's a UK based company that I am a customer of anyway so hopefully that will help - request logged through their support channels)... I also submitted a Spam notification via Google Sitemaps explaining the situation. Both original domains have longstanding sitemaps associated. On Monday, I intend to call the numbers listed and ask them to remove the content. If that fails I'll be contacting trading standards and considering legal action. There are a number of websites that offer advice on such issues, but I haven't had time to investigate more fully yet. I shall post further updates and developments as they occur. It's probably a good time to remind you to ensure that your websites and content have appropriate copyright notices on display in case this happens to you!
UPDATE: I've had a response from his host (UK2) who have a logged a ticket and given him 1 week to respond (They didn't say that would take action as of yet). UK trading standards don't think they can act and have suggested a solicitor. Still waiting for a response from google. Next step is probably to discuss legal action (possibly via FSB or Edinburgh Chamber of Commerce for an initial consultation at least).
LATEST UPDATE: I contacted UK2 again today and they reported that the owner of the copycat site had not responded with the time limit set. They then reported that he had just submitted a long and rambling reply which would need careful consideration. The UK2 operator also apologised and said that the copy sites should have been suspended which they did do within 30 minutes - currently they are showing a 403 error. I've been advised to wait for a response to my support ticket. We have also looked into legal action at this point and as things stand we have been advised that we stand a good chance of proving that the copycat site is guilty of passing off. It will cost money though so I'm hoping that UK2 will persuade the ripoff merchant to create some of his own content at least. I have heard nothing back via google sitemaps as of yet. UPDATE 27/02/2010 Both offending sites are back up, but with our content removed (as far as I can tell). They are now 1 page sites (although there may be orphan pages on the site still accessible via google and other search engines. The page layout is still mine, and the domain name is still a copycat but I guess I can't expect anything more at the moment.

4 comments:

  1. I've found another 2 websites owned by the same person that use my content (badly) on copycat urls... I've requested that UK2 suspend the accounts and submitted a spam report to google...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Still waiting to hear back from UK2 this time.. I think they've actually barred me from accessing live support at my office IP... very shoddy. I think Google have removed the listings from their index but I have found another 2 of his domains which are using my content.

    GOOGLE LOCAL: I HAVE JUST CHECKED GOOGLE LOCAL and found him using our business name, linking to completely unrelated businesses! What is this moron doing? And why is he doing it? Surely if he devoted a little of the time and energy he's spent ripping people off to writing his own content then he'd be doing quite nicely. I have reported the offending business to google local as spam... we'll see what happens.

    ReplyDelete
  3. No response from google local yet. UK2 tried to wash their hands so I have sent them a reply threatening legal action. A tedious business - remember never to visit the copycat domain via a search engine as you can boost their rankings...

    www.glasgow-projector-hire.co.uk is still #1 in google for "projector hire glasgow"...

    I am about to rollout an update to the site to make it 1 degree less shoddy (design wise) making sure all code is compliant. I'll also be attempting to update inward links and maintain our ranking...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Latest Update:

    It appears that the rip-off merchant has put our hire stock back up on all his websites. He was appearing above us in google too. The google local info still seems to be there too. I have complained to google again. I am currently exploring the legal route which looks like the only option left to persuade him to stop using our business name(s), website and hire stock.

    It's still unclear as to what he can possibly get out of this business as our hire stock is specialist and expensive. We know that he can't provide it.... All very dull.

    ReplyDelete